Rachel Lee Annotations

Can you suggest ways to collage, add to the framing, or otherwise elaborate this image to strengthen its ethnographic messaging?

Monday, December 3, 2018 - 8:49pm

The image is a powerful representation in the irony of LASPD’s rhetoric and LASPD’s involvement. However, it has a lot of information. I would suggest narrowing the statistical representation on the right side of the image so that you only feature the “LASPD POPULATION VS LASPD INVOLVEMENT Bar Graph"

 

 

Creative Commons Licence

Describe your immediate reception or impression of this image (visceral, emotional, intellectual)?

Monday, December 3, 2018 - 8:46pm

The image feels too familiar. In disability studies we see too often the ways people with disabilities are positioned as naive children in need of guardianship. That comes across in the LASPD Facebook image. And it is a shocking contrast with the statistical information provided next to it.

 

Creative Commons Licence

How is this image “ethnographic”? Would you add anything to this image’s “design statement”?

Monday, December 3, 2018 - 8:45pm

This image is ethnographic in the sense that it is grounded in a community. I would add more image description to the design statement for the sake of ‘thick description.’ This would also make the image more accessible to those who cannot see the details well enough to grasp the overall picture.

 

Creative Commons Licence

What does this image communicate -- topically and/or conceptually? Does the image call to mind particular scholarly arguments?

Monday, December 3, 2018 - 8:44pm

I see the image’s subject as the mismatch in the LASPD’s presentation of themselves as a benevolent force among predominantly black and brown children and the statistical documentation of the LASPD’s racist policing.

Creative Commons Licence

What does the image convey about “toxic subjects” (their character, dynamics, etc.)? (How) Does this image open up the concept of “toxicity”?

Monday, December 3, 2018 - 8:42pm

I see a racist toxicity in the policing practices of the LASPD and the attempted masking of this toxicity. However, I would appreciate the author building their own conception of toxicity.

Creative Commons Licence