In a Curbed article, the author states that the plaza, like all of Columbia’s buildings in the area, is ringed with dozens of security cameras, several forms of hostile architecture (skateboard deterrents, narrow benches, uneven boulders), and security guard patrols as a constant presence throughout the neighborhood. These assertions align with what I found when I interviewed a resident of Grant Houses, who asserted that securitization has increased with both NYPD and Columbia security keeping on eye on the neighborhood, a stark contrast to the narrative of the Expansion as somehow bringing a more welcoming atmosphere. Whereas the previous campus had security, tall concrete walls, tall iron gates, and locks, the new campus directly across the street from the housing developments brings an almost militant and “Big Brother” presence.
Cite as
Anonymous, "Toxi(cameras)", contributed by Isabelle Soifer, Center for Ethnography, Platform for Experimental Collaborative Ethnography, last modified 9 February 2020, accessed 1 May 2024. http://centerforethnography.org/content/toxicameras
Critical Commentary
In a Curbed article, the author states that the plaza, like all of Columbia’s buildings in the area, is ringed with dozens of security cameras, several forms of hostile architecture (skateboard deterrents, narrow benches, uneven boulders), and security guard patrols as a constant presence throughout the neighborhood. These assertions align with what I found when I interviewed a resident of Grant Houses, who asserted that securitization has increased with both NYPD and Columbia security keeping on eye on the neighborhood, a stark contrast to the narrative of the Expansion as somehow bringing a more welcoming atmosphere. Whereas the previous campus had security, tall concrete walls, tall iron gates, and locks, the new campus directly across the street from the housing developments brings an almost militant and “Big Brother” presence.