ntanio Annotations

Nadine Tanio's picture
In response to:

What does this visualization (including caption) say about toxics?

Thursday, March 5, 2020 - 4:57pm

This visualization indexes climate change and political apathy. It is part of a larger photo essay which focuses on global urban coastal places as sites of toxicity. The cycle of flooding and drought in Chennai shape the image and commentary. This visualization is about the toxic politics that surrounds issues of governance and climate change within coastal communities.  

Creative Commons Licence

Can you suggest ways to enrich this image to extend its ethnographic import?

Thursday, March 5, 2020 - 4:48pm

This image is rich with ethnographic import. It is a found image. I would not know how to enrich this image further.

Creative Commons Licence

What kind of image is this? Is it a found image or created by the ethnographer (or a combination)? What is notable about its composition | scale of attention | aesthetic?

Thursday, March 5, 2020 - 4:47pm

This is a found image. It includes a photograph as well as source caption and a "trending" box. The photo is the central focus of critical commentary. I notice one woman in the photograph of dozens of male leaders (political and religious??). Most of the men are wearing white. The woman is in a brightly color sari. One man has a turquoise shirt on and another a tumeric and red colored scarf. They are  oriented toward the photography and are gathered around a fire vigorously burning. Most are standing, behind a seated (on the ground) semi-circle of men. Many stand with hands clasped, posing in assumed prayer.

Creative Commons Licence

Can you suggest ways to elaborate the caption of this visualization to extend its ethnographic message?

Thursday, March 5, 2020 - 4:37pm

I think the caption could be expanded. As I noted earlier, a whole essay is embedded in this visualization. I would like to see more elaboration of the term, "political apathy" as I think that's such a weighted, rich frame for understanding this image.  

Creative Commons Licence

How does this visualization (including caption) advance ethnographic insight? What message | argument | sentiment | etc. does this visualization communicate or represent?

Thursday, March 5, 2020 - 4:33pm

This visualization presents political apathy on climate change by showing the political leaders of Tamil Nadu participating in a discrete event: a ritual praying for rain. The critical commentary is dense and layered. If I understand correctly, the critique of political apathy centers on a critique on inadequate governance and infrastructure to address cycles of flooding and drought in chennai. Yet the photo shows political leaders engaged in an action—its effectiveness in doubt—but they are not displaying apathy. The disjunction provocates. Embedded in this caption is an argument about governance, effectiveness, science, culture...that opens worlds of inquiry.

Creative Commons Licence